Welcome to the end … of Cooperative Cthulhu month! We’ve seen three brand new cooperative Cthulhu games in the last month! How do these stack up against old favorites? It seems fitting to end Cooperative Cthulhu month with a Top 10!

This list is a composite of about 20 different people’s opinions! It was compiled over the last month to try and capture what a community of board gamers think of cooperative Cthulhu games! The data wasn’t clear in some cases, so I made the best judgment I could based on all the ratings I saw! In the end, my preferences tended to shape the final list!
10. Elder Sign

At its core, Elder Sign is really just a dice game, kinda like Yahtzee. But it’s the expansions that keep Elder Sign alive and thematic! Players explore someplace creepy, a museum, an ice flow, the oceans, … and uses dice to help resolve things!

This one may have made the list for nostalgic reasons, but there are so many expansions that keep this game fresh and alive through the years!

A lot of people put this on their list, even if it wasn’t their favorite Cthulhu-esque game! This is a favorite that still comes out from time to time!
9. Cthulhu Rift

I was surprised how much my friends who have played Cthulhu Rift liked it! Not many have played this, but those who had liked it and its roll-and-write simplicity!

Like any good Cthulhu game, players must fight cultists, navigate Arkham, find clues, and plug portals! It’s surprising how well this works in a roll-and-write (kind of) games.

Take a look at our review of Cthulhu Rift to see if you might be interested in this! This is a bit of hidden gem, but all my friends who played this have liked it!
8. Roll For Great Old Ones

Roll For Great Old Ones was one of our favorite cooperative roll-and-write games from the Top 10 Cooperative Roll-And-Write Games! It’s actually quite thematic for a roll-and-write game in this universe!

Every turn, players roll the dice and “COPY TWICE” and mark things off their sheet! Summon creatures! Perform rituals! This is a fairly complicated roll-and-write with lots of stuff going on. See one of the the great laminated sheets above! Everyone has their own sheet as well with different powers!

Even though this is a little more complicated that Cthulhu Rift (previously mentioned at #9), I generally think Roll For Great Old Ones is the better game. See our review of Roll for Great Old Ones here to see if this is something you might like.
7. Eldritch Horror

Although I have never played Eldritch Horror, a lot of my friends spoke up and gave Eldritch Horror a nod! For some of them, it replaces Arkham Horror 2nd Edition! It’s nominally a little shorter and less dense!

It’s also a little different theme! Rather than wandering the streets of Arkham looking for Cthulhoid type creatures, you are more like Indiana Jones wandering the earth! This is an adventure game in the Cthulhu-esque universe with epic combats and thematic treks across the globe!
Some people still prefer Arkham Horror 2nd edition, arguing that Eldritch Horror is not THAT much shorter or THAT much simpler. But, some people prefer Eldritch Horror for that epic sprawling adventure! Either way, it deserved a space!
6. Mansions of Madness: 2nd Edition

I have a complicated relationship with Mansion of Madness. The first time I played the 1st edition of Mansions of Madness, I absolutely hated it! The 1st edition is a one-vs-many game as one player runs the mansion, and the other players play against him! This antagonistic atmosphere really put me off the game.

I did pick up the 2nd Edition of Mansions of Madness on a whim, and I am glad I did! In the 2nd Edition, an app plays the role of the Mansion and the players all work together fully cooperatively to survive! Some people may not love the idea of an app running the bad guys, but I it does work.
Over the years, I have played some fun games of Mansions of Madness, usually on Halloween! The game is creepy and thematic as the app boths runs the game and plays creepy music! There’s a ton of content for the game and I have come to have some really good creepy times playing in this creepy Mansion! Also, a lot of my friends also gave the same props to Mansions of Madness, 2nd Edition.
5. Arkham Horror: The Card Game

Arkham Horror: The Card Game is probably the most divisive game on this list, which is why it is only #5! Some people loved it, and claimed it as their #1 game, and some people said how much they didn’t like it, and other people said that Marvel Champions has completely replaced The Arkham Horror Card Game for them! It’s very similar to Marvel Champions in terms of gameplay, but arguably the Arkham game has a lot more story!?

Still, a small group of my friends in Las Cruces get together and play this regularly! They LOVE it! There’s a ton of story! There is SO MUCH content with new adventures for this game! If you find yourself drawn to this, you will have plenty of content to choose from! Just be careful, as there is a 1st edition and 2nd edition (and newer one which is still compatible with 2nd).
4. Horror on the Orient Express

For a newer game, Horror on the Orient Express went over quite well with my groups! This is basically Cooperative Cthulhu Clue as players work together to solve a mystery while traveling on the Orient Express!

Players have to uncover facts to find out who are the Cultists in your group, with a kind of Clue-like vibe!

At the same time, players must fight Cthulhoid type creatures racing along with the train in the Dreamlands! It doesn’t matter if you solve the mystery if you can’t keep the train and its passengers safe!

There’s an awful lot to this game: it will require a substantial time investment. And there’s a ton of content and expansions! But, like some of us, if you love the idea of an Agatha Christie mystery novel taking place in a Cthulhu-esque world, this is a perfect game for you! See our review here of Horror on the Orient Express to see if this might be a game for you and your group!
3. Death May Die

Death May Die is not the most popular game in my gaming circles, but the people who love it, love it! This was far and away the favorite Cthulhu game of a number of people, which is why it’s so far up the list!

This was far and away Adrian’s favorite game! And I am pretty sure it is one of Mike Heller’s favorite Cthulhu games too!
2. Mythos Tales
:strip_icc()/pic3955344.png)
This one might surprise you … some of you have probably never even heard of this! Mythos Tales is basically Sherlock Homes: Consulting Detective themed with Cthulhu Mythos! Of course, there’s a very good chance you’ll go insane solving the mystery, but that’s par for the course for most Cthulhu games!
:strip_icc()/pic3263742.jpg)
Part of the reason this game ranks so highly is that it hit some of us so hard … in a good way! My friend Joe, at his job as a teacher, was able to engage at-risk readers with this game! The idea of reading stories, looking at maps, and investigating this world was so much fun! It turns out, if you gives someone a reason to read (investigating horror), then they want to read!

This is, unfortunately, long out-of-print, but it’s pretty easy to get a used copy. If you like the idea of being a detective in the Cthulhu world, using Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective mechanics, this is the perfect game for you! (Make sure you get the 2nd edition if you can; if not, make sure you get the errata).
1. Arkham Horror: 2nd Edition

Arkham Horror: 2nd edition has a special place among me and my friends! That’s why it’s #1! It was arguably the first cooperative board game many of us have played, and we embraced all the content for it! I think I personally have all the expansions for it! You’ll notice Arkham Horror: 3rd Edition is nowhere on this list … frankly, most of us saw no reason for investing in the 3rd edition since we still had and loved the 2nd edition!

At the time of this writing, a newer revised 2nd edition called Arkham Horror: Remastered will be coming to Gamefound. It will curious to see how well this does in our hearts and minds!
At the end of the day, Arkham Horror: 2nd edition is one of me and my friends favorite games of all time. Sure, it’s long. Sure, it’s overly thematic. Sure, it’s complex. But me and my friends have had so many fun hours playing Arkham Horror: 2nd edition, it had to be in the #1 spot!


















































































































































































































































































































