Codenames: Critical Role Adventures. A Review From Someone Who Knows Nothing About Critical Role.

Welcome back to cooperative Adventure month! This week, we venture into a fantasy adventure! With words??

We haven’t talked much about Codenames here at CO-OP Gestalt because most incarnations of Codenames are big, competitive team-based party games: Codenames, Codenames: Pictures, Codenames Disney, Codenames Simpsons, etc. (To be fair, the 2-Player Codenames Duet and Harry Potter ones are co-op). We were reminiscing just recently how BIG Codenames was a few years ago! It was all the rage at the original RichieCon!

Well, now there’s a fully cooperative version! Codenames: Critical Role Adventures! This can play a pretty big group! You need at least 2 people (a clue-giver and a clue-guesser), but we had an amazing time with a 5-Player game!

What do we think of the new Codenames: Critical Role Adventures?

Rules

So, this is one time I broke down and just watched a video. The CGE video on how to play works great. It’s an easy watch: I recommend it.

There are also several playthroughs online, but this video was more than sufficient. To be fair, I watched it a few times because I didn’t want to miss any nuances: my friends tend to be rules sticklers, and I didn’t want to miss anything.

There are a more rules in here than in the base Codenames … just enough to be just a touch daunting: so be aware! The new rules add scenarios, leveling-up, deduction, and special powers! So, yes, there are more rules! This isn’t “just” Codenames with a new coat of paint! It’s a lot more!

Critical Role

I know next to nothing about Critical Role. My understanding is that a bunch of people play Dungeons and Dragons online and people watch their adventures? I’ve heard great things.

You don’t need to know anything about Critical Role to enjoy this game! There might be characters or special allusions which might help you immerse yourself in the game if you know Critical Role? Not knowing about Critical Role did not detract from the game at all! (for me and my friends: none of us really knew it either) . If you know anything about Dungeons and Dragons at all, that’s probably all you need. In fact, a lot of the words in the game seemed like they came from more standard Dungeons and Dragons lexicons!

I hyped this game to my friends as Codenames with Dungeons and Dragons …and they were so in!

Components and Gameplay

In Codenames: Critical Role Adventures, you and your friends are going on an adventure! There are three Adventures in the base game, with a map for each one! See the first one above! This map helps you note where you are (so you can save the game and come back: you can save games because each full adventure can be pretty long).

At its core, Codenames: Critical Role Adventures is still Codenames with its main “associate words” mechanism! See above! So, it comes with a little grid and word cards and the clue-giver (now called the Dungeon Master) gives clues to the clue-guessers (now called the party of adventurers!) See above! It looks like Codenames because it still is!

BUT, they’ve actually added quite a bit more stuff above and beyond the base Codenames!

The group plays a party of three adventurers! No matter the number of players, the party is always three characters! The clue-guessers (no matter how many players) operate the three characters as a unit!

These characters have health! Every time that character guesses “wrong” on Codenames board, that character loses a hit point! See the hearts above on Nott/Veth! If any character ever goes to zero hit points, that mission is lost! (And you can replay it … up to a point).

The characters also have experience points! See above! When a character guesses “correctly”, or completes a mission, or many other ways, the characters get experience points! The experience allow them to unlock special powers, upgrade their modifiers, or increase their hit points!

Perhaps the coolest thing in the game is the special powers that get unlocked from experience! The unlocked powers stay under your sheet until unlocked, then you fold them over to activate them!!! See above! That’s kinda cool!

The special powers do some REALLY interesting things! They can help you find cards, count “good” cards around you, avoid death, and all sorts of neat things that base Codenames never did!

There’s a bunch of new tokens that allow the players to “help note” things on the board! Basically, Codenames: Critical Role Adventurers is now a cooperative deduction game as well! A cooperative word game AND a cooperative deduction game!

Each single game of Codenames is a mission where the party of adventurers guesses words! And each mission is very different! If you get through all the missions (each a session of Codenames), then you win!

This really is still Codenames at its core, but with all sorts of new elements like special powers, deduction, hit points, experience, stuff to buy, ongoing story, and cooperative wordplay! All the new things “sound” a little daunting, and it will take you a play or two to get it, but it’s pretty straight forward.

If you play Codenames with your grandma on weekends (like my friend Sara), this might be a little too much.

Cooperative Play

The core Codenames play is still the same. Everybody is on the same team guessing words: there’s always been that flavor of team cooperation in Codenames. But now, there is extra cooperation! Players have to work together to figure out “who do we send to guess”, “who should buy what upgrades”, “how do we spend experience points”, “should we use our powers”, and many other things! There’s a lot more fundamental cooperation as the players all manage the party together!

To be clear, the role of clue-giver (Dungeon Master) still rotates! Or at least, you probably should so everyone gets a chance to DM! It’s still cooperative, as the DM still wants everyone to guess the words correctly!

What we did seemed to work really well: we physically rotated around the table one space per mission! This let everyone rotate through every space on the board! The further seats had a little glare, so in all fairness to everyone, everyone got sit in every seat at least a few times!

And this fully cooperative nature keeps EVERYONE involved all the time! One of the problems with base Codenames is that one team is always “not playing” and that always seemed less fun (although some of my friends liked to guess poorly to “help” the other teams). With cooperative Codenames: Critical Role Adventures, everyone is always playing and looking at the board!

Number of Players

So, you can’t play this solo. Sorry. Someone has to give clues, some people have to guess.

We played with a group of five, and that worked extremely well! I think four or five might be the best count? I think it really depends on the dynamics of your group! I do worry that six or more people “might” be stretching it too much as “too many cooks spoil the pot”? Again, it depends on your group.

Fun

To be clear, we spent 4 hours on a Saturday playing through a full adventure! We lost the entire game after we failed one mission 4 times in a row, but we were so despondent that we “mulliganed” our last game and powered through to the end of the adventure! Sure, there’s an asterisk next to our “win” but we didn’t care! We had SO MUCH FUN! Why else would you play for four hours if you weren’t having fun?

Conclusion

Codenames: Critical Role Adventures was a giant hit with me and my friends! Yes, it adds more rules and more mechanisms into the game, but the cooperative nature, player advancement, cooperative deduction, ongoing adventure, adding powers, just all worked so well together! If you need a reason to play a bunch of Codenames sessions, the adventure gives you that reason!

This Codenames is complicated enough that it’s “probably” not for Sunday night with Grandma (but hey, you know your Grandma better than I do). Be aware of the extra complexity.

Let’s be clear: at its core this is still Codenames! I have a couple of friends who really don’t like Codenames and I don’t think this new version will change their mind at all !! Despite all the cool new features, this is still Codenames, the word-guessing game. EDIT: Actually, one of my friends who doesn’t love Codenames says this is probably his favorite way to play if we are going to play; so that’s a win?

This is, simply put, my favorite version of Codenames! Codenames: Critical Role Adventures is a 9.5/10 for me and my group! Why else would we have played it for 4 hours straight???

If I were to say what tipped it over the edge to being so great, I would say it was the cooperative deduction aspect as enabled by the special powers!

Prepping for the Standardized Test: A Review of A Carnivore Did It!

A Carnivore Did It! is a cooperative and solo game of logical deduction where players only use logic to discover the solution  (as opposed to social deduction, where players deduce using very human tells).  I ordered this directly from the Horrible Guild website and it arrived late October 2025

Let’s take a look!

Unboxing and Gameplay

This is a pretty small package: see Can of Coke above for perspective.

This is a game where you have to deduce (via logic) “who is the culprit” (or in later games, “who are the culprits“)?   There are from 3 to 7 suspects, depending on the case. See above.

There are 2000 cases (!) in the game; see the cases on 20 cards above (100 cases per card).

Each card has 50 cases per side.

Using a little card overlay above,  you choose a case with its solution.

The line describes the “statements” needed for the case .. see above for case #1.  We need statements 31, 2 and 10.

There are 50 statement cards with different true/false statements: see above.

And the solution is in exposed by the red acetate on the back side (see above, slight spoiler, except its so hard to read, it doesn’t matter).

The case is specified by the numbers: the numbers choose “statements” each suspect will make.  See above for statements 31, 2, and 10.

These statement are attached to the suspects (in order) so that each statement has a statement which is either true or false.

At the top of the case card, it tells you How many suspects you need (3), how many Culprits are there (1 mask), and how many LIES are being told (the red X1).  All the cases on this card share these characteristics.

Then, using the fact that there is EXACTLY 1 lie (or 2 truths, or whatever the card says), you have to deduce who’s lying, and who’s telling the truth.  The statements veracity or falsehood will indicate who the culprit is!   Fun fact; the suspect lying MAY NOT be the actual suspect. People just lie sometimes!

This is a pretty compact little logical deduction game.  The components are fine, except for one thing: see below.

Solo Mode

This is a Solo Team type of game; all players must work together to come up with the final answer of who did it.  So the solo mode is implicit; the solo player works together with himself to solve the puzzle!

I gotta be honest; A Carnivore Did It!  feels like the logic puzzles you find on standardized tests like the GRE and PSAT and SAT (although it’s been a long time since I took those); you use logic to figure out the culprit.  So, playing this solo somehow gave me vibes of doing a standardized test, but without the #2 pencil and little bubbles.

To be fair, I LIKE the logic puzzle this presents.  But, if you don’t really like these logic puzzles because it DOES remind of standardized tests, you will hate this solo.  You may still like it cooperatively (see below).

Cooperative Play

The cooperative play went as expected.  Sometimes you get lost in each others thoughts, as they try to explain their reasoning.

It was VERY important to come up with a systematic system to eliminate/verify statements, especially in the cooperative game!  We ended up using the Trouble and Rare tokens from Kinfire Council to be False and True (respectively). See above.  Without these tokens, I think it’s too easy to get lost in each other’s logic.  Or just to get lost.  If we were sure of a statement’s veracity/falsehood, we would add the token to the RIGHT side of the card.  During hypothesis phase, we’d out a token on the LEFT side of the card to show “it’s just a hypothesis”.

Somehow, it’s a little less daunting to play with someone else, because it forces you to be more systematic.  Even better, If you are flailing, then you can defer to your friend.

Cooperative was a little more fun than solo, even if we had to argue/prove a little bit more.

Issues

Trouble Reading: I really had trouble reading the solution.  I had to zoom in with my phone (see above) and I still could barely read the answer.

In fact, we tried using the little red acetate from Cantaloop to see if it worked better!

It worked “a little better”, but it was still hard to read!

No Explanation:  So, I/We have been able to reason out all the puzzles we’ve have seen … so far.  But what if you are wrong?  You have no place to go to see a solution.  I wish they had a web page you could go to to see the solution for each one.  But there is NO explicit solution in the rulebook at all.  All you get is an answer … the game does not “show its work”.

Clumsy and Frail;  You have to slip the little decoder on the cards.  This felt fraught with peril; I was very afraid it might break over time or maybe you accidentally tear it when you slide it down the card.

Stuff I Liked

Lots of cases: Yes, 2000 cases!

Very Clear Presentation!  The rulebook even does a good job of discussing when things would still be true or false, to help answer some of the “well, what do they mean by THAT“.  The and/or questions … they have a little section to help discuss that. Still, the AND/OR stuff can be confusing.

Conclusion

You probably already know right away whether you will like this game or not.  If you love logic puzzles, I think this game will really resonate with you.  A Carnivore Did It! reminds us a lot of the simpler logic deduction game Cat Crimes (see our Top 10 Cooperative Cat Games here).

If you liked the simpler Cat Crimes, then A Carnivore Did It! is the next step up in complexity (especially when you have 7 suspects and multiple culprits)!  The later cases (see one above) can be pretty challenging (but still doable).

If you don’t like logic puzzles, you will probably hate this as a solo game; it probably feels too much like a standardized test.  Even if you don’t like logic puzzles, you may still like this cooperatively; sometimes it’s fun to be a fly on the wall and all of a sudden start participating and getting involved when you see the solution unfolding!  Or you may hate it and feel stupid and just draw away.  Only you know you.

This would probably get a higher rating if there weren’t a few component issues.  This should be probably be a solid 7.5/10 or even better, but the fact the little acetate reader is really hard to use, hard to read, and possibly fragile, I worry. I also wish they had they shown their work for solutions.  So, this might be a 6.5 or 7/10 instead.  Or maybe it won’t bother you, and this is exactly what you wanted: “I can read the solution, and I don’t need them to show their work … I can figure it out myself!”  If that’s the case, you may love this game and embrace it with aplomb …  for an 8/10 game.